A number of people have sent me this link, amazed that an elephant can do such a thing. I have spent a lot of time in Asia, and I feel compelled to respond.

First, it is NOT the elephant’s idea to paint an elephant! It is a man’s idea, and the elephant has been “trained” to do it. Training of elephants invariably uses the hook, or Ankus, and often nails, which are thrust into the elephant’s sensitive skin. They have probably done that painting dozens of times. Sorry to say it, but this is just another circus act!

The first time I saw an elephant painting was 2001, at the Elephant Conservation Center in Thailand. At that time an easel was placed in front of the elephant and the mahout would hand the elephant a paintbrush with a color on it; Then another color and so on. Actually one could distinguish some “styles” from one elephant to another. I bought one for 500 Baht (then $12.00)! A few years passed, and suddenly they were being sold at fancy western auctions, for hundreds, then thousands of dollars. I checked out a website, and wondered How do they get an elephant to paint bouquets of flowers? with leaves and Japanese-style petals? The most recent time I saw it, two years ago, I was up close, standing next to the mahout as the elephant painted a painting . The mahout was constantly moving the elephant’s head, often by the tusk, to make the trunk land exactly where he wanted it on the paper. Sure enough, flowers, stems and leaves miraculously appeared. You’ll notice in this video that you don’t see the mahout, carefully placed the other side from the audience. It’s a bit like a Magician act – one wouldn’t notice anyway, due to being absorbed watching the elephant.

And so the form has evolved. Paintings make a LOT of money these days. Where does it go? conservation? really?

Now they have taught them to paint elephants. You’ll notice how careful the elephant is, hesitant, a little shaking, as she places her trunk on the paper. Because it HAS to be right!

I am not stating categorically that an elephant could not enjoy painting. They ARE incredibly intelligent, and I can imagine they could have fun with it. However, in all cases we see today, in captivity, they have been taught. They live on chains and are usually severely beaten for not obeying a command. There is NO freedom of choice. Once they have learned something, the hook does not always have to be used. However, it’s presence is a constant reminder of former terrifying experiences, when they were forcibly taken away from their mothers and bruatally “trained”.

I am also not stating categorically that elephants cannot be trained without cruelty. I know that they can. But in Asia, Africa and circuses the general belief is that dominance and power is essential to control such a big animal, so get them when they are young. There generally isn’t the concept that they have feelings, which of course they do, and there’s plenty of research to back that up.

Painting pretty pictures for our amusement is not what this huge magnificent mammal, an endangered species, should be doing. She should be roaming free, with her mother, playing and foraging for food – in the jungle.