Did you know that your version of Internet Explorer is out of date?
To get the best possible experience using our website we recommend downloading one of the browsers below.

Internet Explorer 10, Firefox, Chrome, or Safari.

This Guy Justified Commodifying Animals by Talking About The Circle Of Life

Like us on Facebook:

The Albany Herald has me singing “the circle of life.”

A guest columnist by the name of Doug Porter has decided to weigh in on animal life in captivity, and actually thinks that humans are helping (not using) the animals we imprison. He refers to the death of Chai, a beloved elephant of the Seattle zoo, as a “byproduct of the circle of life.” By his logic, death in a cage is as natural as death in the wild.

One fact he shares (from the Wildlife Conservation Society)  is that “in 2012 alone some 35,000 elephants were killed in Africa, which works out to an astonishing 96 animals killed every day.” These numbers work hard to justify Chai’s passing, arguing that a longer life in chains somehow trumps what could happen to elephants left alone in Africa. I think he’s forgetting the obvious rationale that captivity isn’t in any way natural, or something an elephant chooses. He certainly escapes mentioning what humans have to gain from keeping them as exhibits.

I’d like to pose this logic to Porter with humans in place. Is it okay to imprison a child if we think that’ll help them live longer? Could we forcibly contain people against their will, because it’ll keep them away from danger? These scenarios wouldn’t fly. But somehow, we continue to believe that we know what’s best for other species, and that they’re somehow incapable of living well without us. This is just one excuse that lets us continue selling tickets to gawk at them.

Just like in many other cases, this is an example of humans trying to justify the commodifying of animals, and fooling others in to feeling good about it. Chai the elephant, and all others, don’t ask humans to intervene on their morality rates. Doug Porter might not mourn the death of one elephant because it happens everyday, but we should all mourn the animal life that isn’t left alone to live in the first place.

Like us on Facebook:
0 Comments
  • vegan truth seeker

    Actually, humans are the only species that if it became extinct it would allow Nature to thrive!

    Humans are like a virus – we’re feeding off, weakening and killing our host (Earth) even though we fully depend on it.

    Nature doesn’t need us but we need it… we’re not special people!

Beyoncé and Jay-Z sell out veganism for ticket giveaway

Veganism deserves better than constantly being considered something to be bribed, dared or loosely entered into.

Month one of “the year of the vegan”

News outlets are abuzz with the promise of new vegan products, celebs, and services and how that is somehow a fresh affirmation that our world is one turn closer to being fully free from animal use.

What About: “No-Kill” Eggs?

The reason for these advancements is not a sense of justice – because that can only mean going vegan – but is primarily driven by economics.

Vegandale Brewery offers the ultimate vegan night out

This brewpub helps veganism shed its stay-home-and-eat-tofu stereotype.

Don’t blame vegans for the shame you feel about using animals

The shame Carly Lewis claims veganism casts over her is more likely the ghosts of moral uncertainty, spectres that are more likely fish than cows, wondering how morality can possibly be used as ammunition in favour of murder.